Reviews

Write A Review

Grills & Smokers

Stoves & Fireplaces

Green Egg Grills

All Reviews

Grills & Smoker Reviews

Excellent

4.9

review us on

Glenn D

Friendly and helpful. I bought a grill there several years ago and they are ordering parts for me since the model is out of production now.

Response from the owner: Glenn, thank you for your kind thoughts. We were glad we could get you that grill and new parts!

Noah Alexander

If you love to bbq this is a hot spot lots of grill options and pellets to choose from. All of the best popular seasonings.

Response from the owner: Thank you Noah!

Zack Weiford

Very high quality everything. If you like outdoors or grilling get everything you need from patio furniture and gazebos to high end grills and spices.

Response from the owner: Zack, thanks for taking the time to write about your positive experience you had with Coalway!

David Baird

Excellent service and values! They have everything you need for your grilling and smoking meats you need! Many types of BBQ sauces and rubs!

Response from the owner: David, glad you liked our BBQ Showroom! We appreciate the positive words.

stacy mccourt

I drove 286 miles one way to look at the Yoder ys640s. I had done some research and wanted to see it in person, this was the closest one. Upon arrival was greated by a friendly staff and Milan showed and answered all my questions concerning the grill. I left with a new one and some add-ons. Wished I would have had more time to spend looking at the rest of the store, but I will make a drive back up there and spend some time looking at their wood stoves. Thanks for the help Milan.

Response from the owner: Stacy, thank you for making the drive to get the Yoder Smoker. We are deeply appreciative of your kind words and business.

Robert McKee (Jonsered)

Had what I wanted but was a little pricier than I was looking to spend on a wood grill.

Response from the owner: Robert, glad we had what you were looking for, but we apologize the price was out of your budget. Hoping we can help you in the future with any other need you may have!!

Greg Vogel

Did a bunch of research on new Smoker Grills and came across the GMG and found you guys as a dealer. A little farther but sounded like you had a great selection. Came over and was not disappointed. The help was out of this world and I have used this grill way more than I thought I would. Its been about a year and had a problem with the display. Called and they helped me with how to go about getting the warranty done. Parts are being shipped today and an actual person answered the phone on both ends. Cant say how glad I am that I purchased from you! Highly recommend.

Response from the owner: Thank you Greg... We appreciate your business and your testimonial!

Craig Kinsley

Super friendly and knowledgeable staff. Great place and atmosphere, perfect for buying a grill.

Response from the owner: Thanks Craig! We appreciate your business.

Larry Coleman

Fun store to visit if your into anything that involves wood burning, grilling, smoking, and outdoor cooking. Friendly staff.

Response from the owner: Thank you Larry!

David Barber

They have a great BBQ section. They have tons of grills, smokers, bbq rubs, Pellets and accessories. I like because they carry Yoder Smokers and I can buy all my accessories there and not have to purchase online.

Response from the owner: Thanks David!

Dean Fitzsimmons

Good selection of BBQ grills and smokers.

Response from the owner: Thank you Dean!

Nevaeh Perrella Ph.D

we had issues with our grill but they did make it right .

Response from the owner: Thanks for working with us!

Brent Miller

I love this place!! You'll find everything you need pertaining to grilling or smoking!

Response from the owner: Thank you Brent...We appreciate your business!

Paul Sommers

Excellent seller, very knowledgeable about fireplaces, wood stoves grills, smokers, anything to do with fire good place to do business

Response from the owner: Thank you Paul...we appreciate your business!

michelle sellers

Nice, clean place. Nice section of quality built smokers, grills and BBQ sauces and rubs.

Response from the owner: Thanks Michelle!

Micah Troyer

Friendly staff, good products, all you need and anything you want to grill up a good time on a green egg or smoker. (Minus the meat) Highly recommend.They now take credit cards

Response from the owner: Thanks Micah!

Butch Miller

Great service, grills , smokers, stoves, fireplaces and accessories.

Response from the owner: Butch, thank you for the kind words!

Matt Brewer

Went here twice looking for a new grill/smoker. I went once by myself and once with my wife. I would recommend the trip to anyone considering. There is a wealth of product knowledge and the 2 gentlemen that we talked to were very patient with me and answered every question I had. I bought a Yoder Smoker YS640 and am really enjoying it. Need to go back and get more pellets. I would definitely buy again and I would definitely buy from These guys again. Thank you for a great experience.

Response from the owner: Matt, we are thankful for your purchase of the YS640s pellet smoker. Glad you are enjoying it, and than you for your kind words and taking a moment to leave us a review.

Ryan Campbell

Great place to buy wood for smoking and have great quality of grills and smokers.

Response from the owner: Ryan, thank you for the review. Glad you enjoy our quality products!

Stove & Fireplace Reviews

Excellent

4.9

Jan Swartz

Due to housing codes, we had to install a stainless steel pipe extension to our wood burning fireplace insert. We have had the insert since 1996 when we built the house. The gentlemen at Coalway were very helpful in explaining exactly what was needed and how they would install it. Since their price was half what someone else quoted us, we went with them. They did the install in a timely manner, covered all our hardwood floors, pulled the insert without damage, thoroughly cleaned everything when they were finished and we have been using the insert since. They also packed insulation around the pipe and our house has been so much warmer. Would highly recommend Coalway!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your kind words about us Jan! Thank you again for putting your trust in us, to take care of your heating. Glad you guys are staying warm in there!

Dave D

Great selection of stove parts and accessories.

Response from the owner: 👍🔥

Cathi Pifer

Needed a new gas fireplace insert, and Coalway was the best! They were knowledgeable, professional, and fair priced. Aaron, Joey, and the installers were great to work with. Thank you Coalway!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your business and positive feedback Cathi!

TJ Herberger

I’ve got 2 fireplace upgrades made in 2019 & 2017 & the installation work is EXCEPTIONAL! I’m VERY SATISFIED today in 2023!!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your business greatly TJ!

Sally Ladrach

Incredible company run with integrity and grace. I won’t share the whole story here, but they went above and beyond in helping us return a stove my late father in law had bought when I thought we wouldn’t be able to take it back at all.Stand up people, and stand up company. You won’t regret doing business with coalway.

Response from the owner: Sally, we are so thankful for you and your kind words. We were overly glad to help you and your father in law! Hope to see you again in the future!

K L

Very helpful staff! Knew exactly what I needed for my wood burning stove!

Response from the owner: Glad we could help you out! ❤

stacy mccourt

Response from the owner: Stacy, thank you for making the drive to get the Yoder Smoker. We are deeply appreciative of your kind words and business.

Paul Sommers

Excellent seller, very knowledgeable about fireplaces, wood stoves grills, smokers, anything to do with fire good place to do business

Response from the owner: Thank you Paul...we appreciate your business!

Jacqueline Martin

Super impressed with this company. They addressed my problem the very next morning after my call and their technician, Corey, took his time and went over everything to make sure I was back in full working order. Corey was a polite well-spoken young man, and thorough. The next day I called because I wanted a different remote for my stove and Paul from Coalway worked with me to get me exactly what suited my needs.

Response from the owner: Thank you for the feedback Jacqueline!

Drewber

Great service here, these guys know what they're talking about. I'll be shopping here for all my fireplace needs.

Response from the owner: Thanks! Hope to see you in the future and help you in any way we can with your fireplace.

Butch Miller

Great service, grills , smokers, stoves, fireplaces and accessories.

Response from the owner: Butch, thank you for the kind words!

Green Egg Reviews

Excellent

Coalway

4.9

Based on 98 reviews

See all reviews

review us on

Micah Troyer

Friendly staff, good products, all you need and anything you want to grill up a good time on a green egg or smoker. (Minus the meat) Highly recommend.They now take credit cards

Response from the owner: Thanks Micah!

All Reviews

Excellent

Coalway

4.9

Based on 98 reviews

See all reviews

review us on

Cindy Mykrantz

Response from the owner: Thanks for the review Cindy!

Jan Swartz

Response from the owner: We appreciate your kind words about us Jan! Thank you again for putting your trust in us, to take care of your heating. Glad you guys are staying warm in there!

Scott Vranich

I was in the market for a new smoker and have been looking at the Yoder 640. Found out Coalway was a Yoder dealer, and only half hour drive away. I want to thank Milan for taking his time with multiple phones calls and his knowledge and great customer service in my purchase of my new Yoder!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your kind words Scott. Hoping you enjoy your new YS640 and let us know if you have any questions in the future. We will be happy to help you out anytime!

Dave D

Great selection of stove parts and accessories.

Response from the owner: 👍🔥

Cathi Pifer

Needed a new gas fireplace insert, and Coalway was the best! They were knowledgeable, professional, and fair priced. Aaron, Joey, and the installers were great to work with. Thank you Coalway!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your business and positive feedback Cathi!

Duane Tufts

Very friendly and knowledgeable staff

Response from the owner: Thank you Duane!

Alan Shafer

We bought a great Green Mountain Grill after reviewing several different models that they have.

Response from the owner: We hope you're enjoying your Green Mountain Grill Alan!

BILL R

Expensive

Response from the owner: Bill, thank you for taking the time to leave the review. We are sorry you found us to be expensive. If you are ever interested in the same product again in the future, keep in mind we offer financing options!

John W.

High quality products, great selection. We've had our Green Mountain Grill for 5 years now and it has worked flawless. Last year we purchased A Berlin Gardens table and 6 chairs we had some minor issues that Coalway quickly addressed. Great business with good customer support.

Response from the owner: Thank you!

Charles P

Very knowledgeable staff and I love my new smoker.Still love my smoker

Bill McDole

Response from the owner: Thanks Bill!

TJ Herberger

I’ve got 2 fireplace upgrades made in 2019 & 2017 & the installation work is EXCEPTIONAL! I’m VERY SATISFIED today in 2023!!

Response from the owner: We appreciate your business greatly TJ!

Glenn D

Friendly and helpful. I bought a grill there several years ago and they are ordering parts for me since the model is out of production now.

Response from the owner: Glenn, thank you for your kind thoughts. We were glad we could get you that grill and new parts!

Sally Ladrach

Response from the owner: Sally, we are so thankful for you and your kind words. We were overly glad to help you and your father in law! Hope to see you again in the future!

K L

Very helpful staff! Knew exactly what I needed for my wood burning stove!

Response from the owner: Glad we could help you out! ❤

Julie Niles-Fry

The search for the Pacific Energy part we needed was daunting due to PE part number changes over the years, and it was Coalway that determined the part and had it in stock. We will now have a warm winter and are appreciative for the service, knowledge, and efficiency of Coalway!

Response from the owner: Thanks Julie for the positive feedback. We were very glad to help you out and get you that part!

Freddie Ray

Very helpful and had what I needed.

Response from the owner: Glad we could help you out Freddie, hope to see you again soon.

Eli Miller

Response from the owner: We appreciate it Eli!

Noah Alexander

If you love to bbq this is a hot spot lots of grill options and pellets to choose from. All of the best popular seasonings.

Response from the owner: Thank you Noah!

Shawn Kapfhammer

Very knowledgeable and they have a great selection of a ton of Accessories barbecue sauces and seasonings

Response from the owner: Thanks Shawn for the review!

Gary Connor

This was one of the highlights of my trip. Spent an hour with Aden talking everything smoke. Green Eggs, Yoder, Traegar equipment. Taste testing rubs and sauces. Just a great experience.

Response from the owner: Gary, we are so thankful for you stopping in. Glad you and Aden could converse about grilling and everything smoke. Your positive experience and kind words mean a lot to us. Thanks again!!

bill latham

Holly Grimm

Beautiful store with quality merchandise

Response from the owner: Holly, thank you for your nice words. Glad you enjoyed our store!

Jennifer Urban

Laura N

Gentlemen was very helpful. He had set good ideas and guide me to what would work better for me.

Response from the owner: Glad our team could give you the best advice and plan possible Laura!

Rudy Cooper

Very nice and helpful just what a person is looking for I will be back

Response from the owner: Thank you Rudy for the review! We can't wait to see you again in the future.

Kellogg Hill Farms

Awesome service, knowledgeable staff. Very highly recommended!!!

Response from the owner: Thank you!!

Kenneth Mccracken

Response from the owner: Thanks Kenneth!

Leroy Bowman

Response from the owner: Leroy, thank you!

Shawn Nolt

Knowledgeable and friendly customer service. Great selection. Highest quality.

Response from the owner: Thanks Shawn!

Tom Winter

Response from the owner: Thanks Tom

Jerry Thein

The people their are the nicest people on the planet..

Response from the owner: This is such a kind compliment to our team members. Thank you, Jerry.

Kimberly Newton

Response from the owner: Thank you Kimberly!

Zack Weiford

Very high quality everything. If you like outdoors or grilling get everything you need from patio furniture and gazebos to high end grills and spices.

Response from the owner: Zack, thanks for taking the time to write about your positive experience you had with Coalway!

David Baird

Excellent service and values! They have everything you need for your grilling and smoking meats you need! Many types of BBQ sauces and rubs!

Response from the owner: David, glad you liked our BBQ Showroom! We appreciate the positive words.

stacy mccourt

Response from the owner: Stacy, thank you for making the drive to get the Yoder Smoker. We are deeply appreciative of your kind words and business.

Robert McKee (Jonsered)

Had what I wanted but was a little pricier than I was looking to spend on a wood grill.

Response from the owner: Robert, glad we had what you were looking for, but we apologize the price was out of your budget. Hoping we can help you in the future with any other need you may have!!

Greg Vogel

Response from the owner: Thank you Greg... We appreciate your business and your testimonial!

Jodi Hollinger

Response from the owner: Thank you Jodi!

Benjamin Perrine

Nice place good price realx!

Response from the owner: Thanks Benjamin!

Morgan Thomas

Excellent sales people very great prices

Response from the owner: Thank you Morgan!

Wayne Marty

Very good services

Response from the owner: Thanks Wayne!

Craig Kinsley

Super friendly and knowledgeable staff. Great place and atmosphere, perfect for buying a grill.

Response from the owner: Thanks Craig! We appreciate your business.

Larry Coleman

Fun store to visit if your into anything that involves wood burning, grilling, smoking, and outdoor cooking. Friendly staff.

Response from the owner: Thank you Larry!

David Barber

Staff is great. They will answer any questions you have and are just friendly. Definently worth a trip if you looking for something for your outdoor patio.

Response from the owner: Thanks David. We appreciate you're business!

David Barber

Response from the owner: Thanks David!

Scott Stewart

Some of the nicest smokers I've seen

Response from the owner: Thank you Scott!

Ron Krys

Friendly and knowledgeable staff

Response from the owner: Ron, we thank you for the positive words about our staff!

Paul Sommers

Bryce Hashbarger

Charles Hollan

Response from the owner: Thanks Charles!!

Mike

Great people, high prices but you get quality products.

Response from the owner: Thanks Mike! We appreciate your business!

Matthew Schrock

Response from the owner: Thank you Matthew!

Larry Davis

Response from the owner: Thanks Larry!

Dean Fitzsimmons

Good selection of BBQ grills and smokers.

Response from the owner: Thank you Dean!

G Stu

Response from the owner: Thank You!

Nevaeh Perrella Ph.D

we had issues with our grill but they did make it right .

Response from the owner: Thanks for working with us!

Rebecca McKibben

Brent Miller

I love this place!! You'll find everything you need pertaining to grilling or smoking!

Response from the owner: Thank you Brent...We appreciate your business!

Jacob Keim

Response from the owner: Thanks Jacob!

Paul Sommers

Excellent seller, very knowledgeable about fireplaces, wood stoves grills, smokers, anything to do with fire good place to do business

Response from the owner: Thank you Paul...we appreciate your business!

michelle sellers

Nice, clean place. Nice section of quality built smokers, grills and BBQ sauces and rubs.

Response from the owner: Thanks Michelle!

Jason Hall

Good place to deliver freight too

Response from the owner: Thank you Jason!

Tyler Sturgis

Great place. Paul helped me purchase and arrange delivery of a Yoder smoker. They have some tough-to-find dry rubs and sauces as well. Will be back.

Response from the owner: Thanks for your review Tyler, and for being a great customer!

Stephanie Howell

Response from the owner: Stephanie, we appreciate your review.

Jacqueline Martin

Response from the owner: Thank you for the feedback Jacqueline!

Drewber

Great service here, these guys know what they're talking about. I'll be shopping here for all my fireplace needs.

Response from the owner: Thanks! Hope to see you in the future and help you in any way we can with your fireplace.

Harley Mani

Great selection

Response from the owner: Glad you liked our selection of products Harley!

Ann Jones

Owner was very knowledgeable and friendly. Answered all our questions. His helper was very friendly and helpful. Got all the information we needed. Will go back again if we decide to purchase from them. Highly recommend this place.

Response from the owner: Thank You Ann!

Ann Jones

Had woodburning insert installed. Workers were friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. Great to work with. Answered all our questions and demonstrated how to use the insert before they left. Highly recommend coalway. Great job!

Response from the owner: Ann, thank you so much for the review, we are thankful for your business.

Ben Morris

My wife and I are beyond pleased with this place! Awesome staff and amazing service!! They really treat you like family.

Response from the owner: Ben, thank you for stopping by! We appreciate your positive words about Coalway.

Scott Sommer

Response from the owner: Thank you Scott!

Kevin Lee

Response from the owner: Kevin, thank you!

Robert Lachendro

Response from the owner: Thanks Robert for the 5 star review!

Micah Troyer

Friendly staff, good products, all you need and anything you want to grill up a good time on a green egg or smoker. (Minus the meat) Highly recommend.They now take credit cards

Response from the owner: Thanks Micah!

allie gator

EDIT- they now accept credit cards! As of early Feb,2019. Very helpful with enviro bricks and coal. Only downside is they don't take credit cards. Cash or checks.

Response from the owner: Thanks for the review!

Lori Sink

Response from the owner: Lori, thanks for the review

Butch Miller

Great service, grills , smokers, stoves, fireplaces and accessories.

Response from the owner: Butch, thank you for the kind words!

Matt Brewer

Response from the owner: Matt, we are thankful for your purchase of the YS640s pellet smoker. Glad you are enjoying it, and than you for your kind words and taking a moment to leave us a review.

Joseph Black

Response from the owner: Joseph, thanks for the positive review! We appreciate it

Ryan Campbell

Great place to buy wood for smoking and have great quality of grills and smokers.

Response from the owner: Ryan, thank you for the review. Glad you enjoy our quality products!

Shout out to Coalway Fireplaces LLC!! They installed out fireplace when we built our home, we were having issues with the fan running when we were in the Arctic blast cold spell. They came right away and got it fixed up. They come every rear to clean and service the fireplace and I couldn’t be happier with their top notch service. Shop local– when there is an issue it’s much easier to get help! – Audra Miceli

I just had a load of coal delivered today. I want to thank you so much. That young man Aaron, that delivered it is such a friendly man. I am happy with the coal and your company. I just want to let you know you’re doing a great job. I plan to purchase a lot more coal from you in the future. I will be praying to succeed and prosper. I’m just letting you know I’, well pleased and God bless – Alvin Hickling

Hey! Thank you very much. Your service was prompt and done right. I am so happy how you fixed my stove and did it right in a timely manner. – Wayne Roser

We had to make an impromptu trip to Amish country to get a piece of glass for our wood stove.
Tried to close the door on a log that was wedged.
Big shout out to Coalway in Apple Creek for finding and holding a replacement window for us. If you
are looking for a top quality wood burner give Aiden a call. They sell Pacific Energy stoves and they
are as efficient, smoke free, and functional as anything on the market!
All fixed up and back to toasty iguana terrarium temp again! – Eric Hirzel Sr.

Thank you for your time and patience helping us pick out just the right furniture. – John & Ellen Deangelis

I recently bought a BBQ42 at Coalway, in Apple Creek Ohio. They promptly returned my phone calls they were informational and kind. They made my 5 hour round trip worth the while. Great Product. Thanks – Dan

Your guys installed a Pacific Energy wood stove for us this week. I just want to let you know this stove is such a superior stove to what we had and its so easy to keep it going and no smoke and a lot of other good things I could say about it. The guys did such a good job and we are so satisfied with the product and your service. – Gaylord & Betty Dotterer

You have helped me order an electric fireplace insert for my parents for Christmas, and you did some extra research because we were going to put in an existing masonry fireplace. You recommended a different unit from what I asked for and were able to have it delivered directly to my home right before Christmas so my parents could have it for their Christmas present. It fits perfectly in their fireplace and it does have the flickering lights like I had asked for and my mother enjoys it every evening and it was a great success. I just wanted to say thank you so much everything was appreciated. – Nadene Whiteman

Thank you for the chance to continue to receive your Fireside Conversations paper by mail. We have no computer and miss out on so many things. – Mr. John J. Just

Just letting you folks at Coalway know how much we appreciate the service you provided for us yesterday. We will recommend your company to our friends in hopes of bringing you more business. Thank you. – Jon & Laura Miller

I just want to tell you what a great job those guys did installing my fireplace. They were very respectful and cleaned things up very well. Those two guys are worth their weight in gold! I love my fireplace. – Myron Miller

Aaron, Cory, and Aidan, thank you for the fine work installing our fireplaces! – Dominique & Michelle Holl

Dennis, Corey, and Dwight did an outstanding job on our stone installation. Dennis and the team were at all times extremely personable, polite and professional; taking time to methodically and aesthetically lay out the stone, working continuously to complete the job in the time allotted for it; and then thoroughly cleaning-up before leaving. As a team they worked very well together and their knowledge, experience, and skill was very evident. We look forward to many years of enjoyment of our Coalway fireplace. We send our best wishes to everyone there.”

David and Rebecca Morris

For anyone reading this, the team at Coalway cannot be beaten. From the folks we spoke to in-store, Aaron who quoted the job, to Cory and Dennis on installation. Their service is top-notch. Their entire team took the time to understand our needs and deliver exactly what we were looking for. Coalway provided the best value for our dollar and as the pictures show, did an excellent job installing a PE Alderlea T6 in our 200-year-old home. We can’t thank the Coalway team enough.

G. Vicich

Let us know how we did!

Leave a Google review