Revive Your Fireplace with High-Efficiency Inserts

Enhance the look and efficiency of your home with wood, gas, coal, or pellet inserts.
Schedule A Call

Turn Heat Loss into Savings with Our Custom Inserts

Make your fireplace work smarter, not harder.

Is your traditional fireplace pulling more heat out than it’s putting in? This is a common issue, but there’s a solution! Our high-efficiency inserts are designed to dramatically improve your fireplace’s performance while transforming its look. Whether you prefer wood, gas, coal, or pellet options, we have the perfect model that can turn your inefficient fireplace into an energy-saving powerhouse.

Ready to Transform Your Fireplace?

Gray circle with the state of ohio in the center. Text reads serving Ohio for over 20 Years
Coalway is NFI certified
Circle icon for certified chimney sweep by chimney safety institute of America
Black circle with red delivery truck

Wood-Burning Inserts

Turn your inefficient fireplace into a powerful heat source with a wood-burning insert. We supply models from Pacific Energy and True North Stoves provide long-lasting warmth and burn for 8-12 hours per load. When installed properly, they provide as much heat as any freestanding stove, while drastically reducing heat loss through the chimney.

  • Burns for up to 12 hours on one load
  • Requires a stainless steel liner for optimal efficiency
  • Wide selection of styles to complement your home’s interior
TN20 Wood Inserts

Gas/Propane

Convert your old fireplace into a high-efficiency gas furnace, enhancing both the warmth and feel of your home. Whether you’re using natural gas or propane, we offer dozens of design options, ensuring a perfect match for your home’s decor. Equipped with advanced remote control features, including thermostat settings, flame modulation, blower control, and more, most models—like the Chaska and Roosevelt series from Kozy Heat—offer an easy-to-use, energy-efficient heating solution with electronic ignition, eliminating the need for a standing pilot light.

  • Thermostat and remote-controlled operation
  • Modern, sleek design options
  • Energy efficient with electronic ignition
Nordik 34i Fireplace inserts

Coal Inserts

For those seeking powerful, long-lasting heat, the DS Stoves Anthra-Max coal insert is an excellent choice. Made in the USA with superior craftsmanship, this model features innovative smoke and gas re-burn systems, maximizing efficiency while maintaining durability.

  • Burns coal with 24-48 hour burn time
  • Gravity-fed coal hopper for consistent heat
  • Large viewing window and easy-to-use design
Fireplace inserts

Pellet Inserts

Looking for an efficient, low-maintenance heating option? Our True North pellet stoves and inserts provide a clean-burning, eco-friendly alternative to traditional heating. With simple operation and easy maintenance, these are designed for long-lasting performance, helping you keep your home warm with minimal effort.

  • Clean burning and eco-friendly
  • Durable, with low emissions
  • Wide firepot for rich, full flames
TN40 Pellet Inserts

See What Our Customers Are Saying

Due to housing codes, we had to install a stainless steel pipe extension to our wood burning fireplace insert. We have had the insert since 1996 when we built the house. The gentlemen at Coalway were very helpful in explaining exactly what was needed and how they would install it. Since their price was half what someone else quoted us, we went with them. They did the install in a timely manner, covered all our hardwood floors, pulled the insert without damage, thoroughly cleaned everything when they were finished and we have been using the insert since. They also packed insulation around the pipe and our house has been so much warmer. Would highly recommend Coalway!

Jan Swartz

Great service here, these guys know what they’re talking about. I’ll be shopping here for all my fireplace needs.

Drewber

Very helpful staff! Knew exactly what I needed for my wood burning stove!

K L

Phone